Pope Francis, the 266th Pope of the Catholic Church is no stranger to controversy but is always looked up to as the Pope who brought a lot of changes. Being the first Jesuit pope, the first pope from the Americas, and the first non-European pope in over a thousand years, he has been noted for his humility and his concern for the poor.
Saint Joseph, you who loved Jesus with fatherly love, be close to the many children who have no family and who long for a daddy and mommy. Support the couples who are unable to have children, help them to discover, through this suffering, a greater plan. #GeneralAudience
— Pope Francis (@Pontifex) January 5, 2022
The Pope recently spoke about how he was seeing selfishness in a new form these days as people were placing more importance on dogs and cats, and allowing them to take the place of 'children'. As per his opinion, the experience of fatherhood and motherhood is essential for our civilisation to understand humanity. He later mentioned that having a child is always a risk, but there is more risk in not having a child.
Children over pets. Photo: Instagram
TWITTER REACTS
Twitter rightfully had strong reactions to these words.
1. AGAIN, WHO IS SELFISH?
Billionaires and oil companies are right there, and Pope Francis is out here calling people with dogs selfish. https://t.co/w0GSVc0wtD
— sarah maclean (@sarahmaclean) January 5, 2022
2. HOW MANY DOES HE HAVE HIMSELF?
How many kids does Pope Francis have? pic.twitter.com/p1imABKPwg
— Cat (@CatFanatic9) January 5, 2022
3. WE DARE YOU TO SAY IT AGAIN!
@Pontifex say it to his face pic.twitter.com/NkWWy89l2x
— i bless the rains down in castamere (@Chinchillazllla) January 5, 2022
4. IT'S EASY TO GET OFFENDED
The Pope and so many others have such a fetishization of the uteruses of women. Stay out of 'em. Not everyone wants kids. Society barely cares about the kids who are already born and need love, shelter, and happy homes. https://t.co/2mGInHQb4O
— THEE Stephanie. (@qsteph) January 5, 2022
5. LET THE BATTLE BEGIN!
Cat twitter getting mentally prepared to drag Pope Francis for saying people who choose pets over having kids are selfish. pic.twitter.com/AyqAlxpggp
— ClockOutWars (@clockoutwars) January 5, 2022
6. WHO WILL PAY THE BILLS?
Is the pope going to pay for my kid's college? https://t.co/l10QSjMVmy
— andi zeisler (@andizeisler) January 5, 2022
THE OTHER TIMES WHEN THE POPE TURNED HEADS
1. THE FINANCIALLY PRUDENT POPE
In the first few years of his tenure, the Pope encouraged the Catholic heirarchs to be financially prudent and responsible. But he eventually showed that he was serious about it by ordering a 10% pay cut for Cardinals across the board, and slashing salaries for Vatican employees. He also imposed a 40 Euro ($45) gift cap, all this to manage the Vatican’s 50-million euro ($57 million) budget.
2. OPEN TO HOMOSEXUALITY, BUT WON'T BLESS THEM
“If someone is gay and he searches for the Lord and has good will, who am I to judge?” When the Pope said these statements, shocks and surprises were expressed around the world. Would these words change the course of the Catholic Church forever?
This statement made LGBTQ magazine The Advocate name Pope Francis as its "2013 Person of the Year". Being the first Pope of the Social Media age, his remark showed a stark contrast between the Church's attitudes towards the LGBTQ community and his personal views. His focus was on loving and accepting a person as a whole, instead of looking at their sexual tendencies to decide whether they receive essential support and guidance.
A Belgian bishop is outraged. German priests are in rebellion. Bishops from Australia to the United States are concerned for gays in their flock. Vatican ruling on same-sex couples has prompted defiance, pain and confusion https://t.co/oIQi5tZhi7 pic.twitter.com/ZlmaFdntOQ
— Philip Pullella (@PhilipPullella) March 17, 2021
But here is the thing: Vatican priests cannot bless same sex unions because such unions are "not ordered to the Creator's plan''. As per the Vatican, Union is defined as the marriage between a Man and a Woman and since same sex unions are "a sin", and God cannot bless sin.
This move alienated the Church from younger followers, who had hoped that the Church would evolve with changing times and would move to liberal beliefs.
Today the Vatican said this about blessing same sex unions: “God can’t bless sin” • I will continue to shed light on the tremendous pain and trauma the church has done to my community, all while affirming everyday that: God loves gay, trans, queer, bi, lesbian... (1/2) pic.twitter.com/rTdXsh4PPC
— Eder Díaz Santillan (@EderEditado) March 15, 2021
3. WELCOME, DEAR FEMALES TO HIGHER TASKS AT MASS. BUT PRIESTHOOD, UMM NO
On a flight from Sweden, the Pope was asked if there ever would be female priests in the coming decades and if not, were they afraid of competition? To this, the Pope mentioned that he was following the declaration made by his ancestor St John Paul II, and that there would never be female priests. But he went on to say how Catcholic history is based on 2 dimensions - the Pastoral activity (male dimension) and the Marian Dimension (feminine dimension) and how the feminine was more important than the masculine.
"The office of priests, since it is connected with the episcopal order, also, in its own degree, shares the authority by which Christ builds up, sanctifies and rules his Body." (Vatican II, PRESBYTERORUM ORDINIS. n. 2) pic.twitter.com/xwkamobNxx
— Father V (@father_rmv) January 5, 2022
In January 2021, the Pope amended the Church law to allow women to administer communion and serve at the altar, but cannot be priests as there is no precedent for female priests. Women are allowed to recite prayers during mass, but gospel readings can be done only by a male priest. This despite churches all over the world experiencing a shortage in the number of priests.
4. SEX SCANDALS
The Church has faced sexual abuse allegations for decades, but senior officials had never really done much except for transferring clergymen to other parishes; as if transferring them would solve the problem. In 2013, Pope Francis created a committee to fight sex abuse and appointed 8 people to the committee in 2014. He publicly apologised for the Vatican's actions (and inactions), but his own actions have not proved to make much of a difference as he seems to only be a man of words.
Maria, a sex abuse survivor who was one of the 8 in the committee, stepped down from the committee since the Vatican resisted from redressing its wrongs and was reluctant to comply with a simple recommendation: to respond to all correspondence from the people who identified themselves as victims of abuse.
The news of child sex abuse rocked the Vatican again in 2016 when Cardinal George Pell, the Treasurer and the third most senior official of the Vatican was charged with multiple sex assaults in Australia. In 2018, George Pell was found guilty of sexually abusing 2 children and was sentenced to 6 years in prison. In April 2020, a bench of the HC ruled for the convictions to be dismissed.
Pope Francis receives Cardinal George Pell in an audience today - Vatican NewsAfter spending 400 days in jail, this past April, he was unanimously acquitted by the Australian High Court of the charge of the sexual abuse of minors.https://t.co/m8T2W9SQ0k pic.twitter.com/4A7LBW7vvV
— Catholic Sat (@CatholicSat) October 12, 2020
Chile had also similarly dealt with the case of Father Karadima, who was sentenced by the Vatican to a “lifetime of penance and prayer” for decades of child abuse and that of Bishop Juan Barros, who was accused of covering up Karadima's act. When Pope was asked to talk about this, he got defensive saying, “The day they bring me proof against the bishop, “then I will speak. There is not a single proof against him. This is calumny! Is that clear?”
He later partially apologised for these remarks as it was a slap in the face for Karadima's victims and an example of lack of empathy.
What do you think about the Pope's recent statement on kids vs pets? Let us know in the comments.