Amazonโs The Rings of Power has been the subject of intense (and often malicious) discussion and criticism since it dropped last month. As it slowly nears its close, we take a look at all that's new with the series.ย
The series currently holds a 38% audience rating on Rotten Tomatoes, in stark contrast to the 84% critics score on the website.ย
Since its conception, the series has been panned online by Tolkien aficionados for reasons other than merit. The series remains just as divisive and each passing episode seems to be a matter of greater contention than the previous.
As one of the largest fandoms in the world, one would assume that most Tolkien fans would yearn for just a single opportunity to relive the experiences that they once had, relishing the nostalgia that a brand-new LOTR project would have to offer. Instead, a significant number of people have made it their lifeโs objective to thrash and defile the series beyond belief. ย
What first stemmed from criticism against the announcement of a more diverse cast of characters for the series, has spiraled out of control into quite literally a witch-hunt against many of the POC cast members of the series.ย
Hundreds of so-called โTolkien fansโ have bombarded the internet with racist and misogynist comments under the poorly-veiled garb of constructive criticism against the show and its performers.ย
Sophia Nomveteโs dwarf queen Disa and Ismael Cruz Cordova's elf Arondir have ritually been subjected to death threats and hate mail since the series premiere and most recently, Morfydd Clarkโs Galadriel has even received flak forโฆ riding a horse. Yes you heard that correctly.
โ galadriel; the rings of power pic.twitter.com/CtWAmC26lI
โ ุ (@tolkiengifs) October 1, 2022
Legolas did skateboard with a shield, jump on top of a horse in a very extra way and take down a giant elephant all by himself, without mention all the unrealistic ways that he fought the orcs on the hobbit trilogy, yet you all had a problem when Galadriel does this. Be serious https://t.co/xxLxAteXUz
โ mabe | trop era โจ (@dragonevenstar) October 2, 2022
Iโm sure you had no problem with Legolas doing this tho pic.twitter.com/Moab6kka4w https://t.co/bPgmsVT1ZP
โ ๐ท (@stormsisobel) October 1, 2022
lemme just translate this rq
โ EL โVarda's Wifeโ (@Bbyulye) October 2, 2022
"I actually tolerate Legolas doing inhumane tricks because he is a male and seeing a woman do the same thing pisses me off because I'm the alpha and I'm the leader. Grrrr" https://t.co/C9D2SsmCtz
The narrative that has been propagated amongst the toxic depths of the community is that this series and those associated with it are a blight upon existence and anyone who supports it is just as bad.
the way people react to certain parts of the rings of power makes me realise that if the return of the king film was released today the same people would almost definitely call รฉowynโs โi am no manโ scene โwokeโ
โ anna ๐น (@myelessar) October 1, 2022
Someone had to say it ๐ #RingsofPower pic.twitter.com/HSaduwlt83
โ Dalton Kaiser (@DaKaiserRoll) September 30, 2022
Among the fair share of truly constructive criticism the series has received, a majority of it has focused primarily on the pacing of the narrative. It seems the hours upon hours of build-up have left fans frustrated and hungry for answers that they have to wait an entire week to receive.ย
Iโm done with the โslow burn/startโ criticism of Andor and Rings of Power. Itโs a shame that action is necessary to get many people interested in a story. Itโs a product of our modern, rushed lives. Nothing stands the test of time these days because people are so easily bored.
โ ษวีผำสสษสสส โ (@DankFerrick) September 30, 2022
it always amuses me when people say that rings of powerโs pacing is slow and could be condensed, as if tolkien didnโt take 50 pages to describe a tree or make morgoth and sauron wait hundreds/thousands of years between defeats before making them do literally anything
โ anthony | halbrand simp โฃ (@REYL0VEBOT) September 27, 2022
The glacial pacing of the series has also been a product of heightening the anticipation surrounding Sauronโs reveal and has had fans tear out their hair in search for answers.
Hereโs a quick recap of who Sauron is and what his motivations are:
Sauronโs suggestive nickname as โThe Deceiverโ has had fans questing for the truth behind his true nature in the series and has manifested itself in a number of hilarious ways on the internet.ย
The summary of Rings of Power so far. #RingsofPower #sauron #ringedermacht pic.twitter.com/jQulF3kCLI
โ Damon Redfield (@damon_redfield1) September 24, 2022
PSA ๐จ๐#RingsOfPower #Sauron pic.twitter.com/MZDxuAhSm0
โ The Wonder of Tolkien (@TolkienWonder) October 1, 2022
everyone in #RingsofPower asking about Sauron all season pic.twitter.com/ren86Epehq
โ ๐ Harish ๐ (@fruitymonkie) October 2, 2022
can you imagine if this was from The Rings of Power we would all be stressing about if Aragorn was actually Sauron ๐ญ https://t.co/6XBhfaiSws
โ Tea with Tolkien (@TeawithTolkien) October 3, 2022
the rings of power fandom tryna to find out who from new unknown characters is sauron who is nazgul who's gonna betray whom #theringsofpower pic.twitter.com/iGzMHFznG9
โ ะปะตะบัั ๐บ๐ฆ (@douxxreve) September 29, 2022
CONFESSION: I ship Halbrand and Galadriel. #RingsofPower #RingsOfPowerOnPrime #lotr #tolkien #LOTRROP #LOTRonPrime
โ Elisabeth Wheatley ๐ (@WheatleyWrites) October 2, 2022
(Do we think he's Sauron?) pic.twitter.com/IyjfpRx4GA
What if Sauron was just the friends we made along the way? #RingsofPower https://t.co/rJJrn9Osax
โ clay b ๐ต (@clayttu17) September 27, 2022
rings of power fan theory stuff is just pointing at every character and going: IS HE SAURON?
โ Carl Marks (@bornposting) October 1, 2022
the best part of Rings of Power was when Sauron said "IT'S SAUR'IN TIME" and saured all over those guys
โ Cranky Federalist (@CrankyFed) September 30, 2022
The latest episode titled โUdunโ has finally switched things up for the series; the entire episode unraveling at a break-neck pace with a gorgeously shot cavalry sequence throwing back to the Ride of the Rohirrim from The Return of the Kingย and featuring a rather โexplosiveโ cliff-hanger that should be quite enough to satiate the needs of both fans and critics alike.
โ galadriel and the eruption of orodruin; the rings of power pic.twitter.com/Uf4y87NmEd
โ ุ (@tolkiengifs) September 30, 2022
Rings of Power Episode 6 might of been one of the best episodes of television Iโve ever seen! #RingsofPower pic.twitter.com/x3O1cCZLBu
โ Jack Sherman (@simple5ive) September 30, 2022
Episode 6 of #RingsofPower was nothing short of absolutely breathtaking television with some jaw dropping cinematography, epic battle scenes and a cliffhanger ending that takes your breath away!
โ NathanMorty๐ฅ๐ฟ (@NathanMort2) September 30, 2022
Can next Friday hurry up please, I NEED answers! pic.twitter.com/RUrLbwnNK9
However, the standouts of the series thus far have been the unlikeliest - the corrupted elf Adar and his family of orcs. In Adar, the series has found a convincing adversary with compelling motivations. Through Adar, we are offered a more humanised perspective towards the otherwise vilified race of orcs and their subsidiaries; one that has even inspired empathy towards the villainous characters.ย
One of my favorite aspects of RINGS OF POWER so far (and one I think Tolkien himself would appreciate) is how the show, particularly through Adar's storyline, wrestles with a question that Tolkien debated with himself throughout his life: are the orcs outside of god's grace?
โ The Once and Future Shane (@ShaneMajszak) September 30, 2022
thank you, #TheRingsOfPower . a soft-spoken, sinister bastard is just what i was looking for. #RingsofPower #LordOfTheRingsTheRingsOfPower pic.twitter.com/yNhj0xcEvb
โ "he's got a ๐ก๏ธ"๐ณ๏ธโ๐ (@titan_boa_) September 27, 2022
Yet the orcs wouldnโt be anywhere near as absorbing were it not for composer Bear McCrearyโs enthralling new war-cry: Nampat. The Black Speech phrase for โDeathโ has had fans captivated for its catchiness and stands testament to the beautiful mosaic of motifs that McCreary has so masterfully crafted for the series.
NAMPAT
โ Eรคrendil (@whitecachalot) September 30, 2022
Means
Rehabilitation and reintegration of the Uruk back into the society through taxation and education of the Elves and Men
me when the orcs were singing nampat at the beginning of the episode vs the end of the episode #tropspoilers pic.twitter.com/MT2exp8FB6
โ justine โ edit pinned!! (@lSlLDUR) September 30, 2022
Nampat = Make Mordor Great Again
โ The Wonder of Tolkien (@TolkienWonder) October 1, 2022
I like how one Orc gets excited and mutters under his breath "nampat..." And then the other orcs hear it and they're like "Oh hell yeah! Hey everybody we're doing Nampat!" And they all start chanting Nampat. I bet that first orc felt really cool.
โ ๐Fall Stalter-Pace๐ (@PaulCPace) October 1, 2022
Iโm rooting for our heroes, but this is me as soon as Nampat drops #RingsofPower pic.twitter.com/UQpVsAWmve
โ MacKenzie (@RSTSnyderVerse) October 1, 2022
๐ถ NAMPAT NAMPAT NAMPAT NAMPAT ๐ถ pic.twitter.com/EYGE4HLohw
โ ๐ Helen S. Pumpkins ๐ (@helenshang) September 30, 2022
Has anyone found themselves unthinkingly going around chanting "Nampat!"? Just me? #TheRingsOfPower
โ Beth Overmyer (@Bethyo) October 1, 2022
Shaking my ass to Nampat
โ tree herder - TROP spoilers (@Bliss_Hughes) September 30, 2022
โNampatโ gonna be everyoneโs top Spotify Wrapped track this year.#RingsofPower
โ Montucky Screwjob (@sgdub66) October 3, 2022
As the series now nears its end, with only two more episodes to conclude its debut season, things are still up in the air for The Rings of Power. Whether or not it sticks the landing, it would more than likely receive similar amounts of backlash regardless.ย
Until then, trust no one. Anyone can be Sauron. Maybe YOU are Sauron. Or perhaps,