Bal Thackeray’s life is worth a movie, but did Nawazuddin Siddiqui face ideological contradiction essaying the role?
Shiv Sena chief, the late Bal Thackeray, had vowed to never pen his autobiography. However, while the Shiv Sena supremo was still alive, his nephew Raj Thackeray came out with a photo-biography on him.
And now, Sanjay Raut, once considered to be Bal Thackeray’s right hand man — some even called him a henchman — has produced a movie Thackeray, which is based on Bal Thackeray’s life.
I believe, had Bal Thackeray been alive, he would have appreciated Raut’s efforts to bring his life to the 70mm screen.
Thackeray’s life was pretty eventful. Quite like a rollercoaster ride, it had many twists and turns, ups and downs.
He made several changes to the stands he took with many calling it hypocrisy.
South Indians were Thackeray’s first target, yet when General Kodandera M Cariappa, a Coorgi, came to Mumbai to stand for the Lok Sabha elections in 1971, against Krishna Menon, Thackeray supported him.
Despite people saying, “Marathi manasachya martat gappa nivdun antat Cariappa (You talk about Marathis but support General Carippa during election),” Thackeray did not back down on his support for the general.
In fact, Thackeray continued making turns and U-turns on several issues. His decision to send Pritish Nandy, a non-Marathi, to the Rajya Sabha left many shocked and confused. His decision to send Sanjay Nirupam was more shocking as Nirupam was exactly the person his party always spoke against.
Known for his anti-Muslim rants and pro-Muslim politics, Thackeray struck an alliance with the Indian Union Muslim League (IUML). He also helped Sanjay Dutt get bail in the 1993 Mumbai blast case.
Despite taking such paradoxical stands on key issues, Thackeray astonishingly commanded massive public support.
I recently interviewed Nawazuddin Siddiqui, the actor who would be essaying Thackeray’s role in the movie now. With due respect to his acting prowess, Nawazuddin’s credentials — a Muslim from the north Indian state of Uttar Pradesh — could have ensured he never got this particular role, had the movie been made by someone other than Sanjay Raut or anyone outside the Thackeray family.
Nawazuddin came prepared with an answer. “Challenge tha. Method acting aise hi sikhayi jaati hai (It was challenging and that is how method acting is taught).”
When Nawazuddin played Saadat Hasan Manto in Manto (2018), he said he could relate to the character.
But how did he deal with Thackeray’s character?
How would a man from a minority community, growing up in northern India, have perceived the anti-minority rants of a leader from Maharashtra — and would it be difficult for such a man to identify with this leader?
I am sure many would say that it is not important for an actor to do so, like it is not important for actors to identify with murderers and gangsters they portray on screen. But Thackeray is a real-life character and the film surely doesn’t aim to just show his life but also how ‘great’ he was, despite all his complexities.
Was there any ideological contradiction in his mind while essaying this character, I asked Nawazuddin.
“An actor cannot have any ideology — else he won’t be able to do his job,” was Nawazuddin’s well-rehearsed reply.
“The producers wanted to make a film like Gandhi (1982) or Long Walk to Freedom (2013) or Lincoln (2012), which were not propaganda films,” Nawaz added.
There is no doubt that Thackeray lived one of the most flamboyant lives. Charismatic and controversial at the same time, Thackeray rose from a humble background in Mumbai and despite having no political backing, went on to form his own political party.
Thackeray knew his political value and hence went on to live an unapologetic life — one that makes for a good film script.
The big question, however, is if we as a country can appreciate a film like this with an unbiased mind, especially given the outrage movies like Padmaavat (2018) have received.
Good that the movie has been made by someone in Thackeray’s camp. Since the movie has blessings from Uddhav Thackeray, it is unlikely to face any resistance at cinema halls.
So, does the film present Bal Thackeray as a hero?
Nawazuddin’s answer was an interesting one.
“You don’t need to be biased before watching a film. We haven’t tried to show him as a hero — he is already a hero.”
Also read: Why Nawazuddin Siddiqui playing Shiv Sena chief Bal Thackeray is a travesty